The Eroding Outsourcing Advantage between India and US
Wednesday, October 8th, 2008I don’t want to talk about the financial crisis or whether that and the new President will cause a growth or a failure of the outsourcing market in India. It’s all been discussed and dissected every which way possible and all we can do is wait until the 1st quarter of next year to see what actually happens. But, what continues to be a great topic for discussions amongst friends and colleagues is the eroding offshore advantage of India. I recently chatted with a friend who said “so what if the prices are going up in India, if a US business is paying $60 an hour locally and can still get the work done for $40 dollars offshore, it’s still a winning argument for offshoring the work”. I tried to explain to her the folly of that argument. I pointed out to her that although an experienced resource may be retained at $60 per hour, that a recent graduate may not demand a $60 per hour rate and that if a company were to get a local resource for $40 or even $45 per hour, they would be less likely to explore offshore options. We had a long heated debate because my friend felt that businesses should be thinking about saving every dollar and if costs could be lowered by even $5, that’s an argument for going offshore. What do you think? I wonder how India will manage the wage hikes and inflation in India and still be a strong contender for offshore work in the future? |

Saturday, October 11th, 2008 at 6:14 am
The driver for offshoring (when outsourcing) due to labor arbitrage will last only as long as there is substantial difference in cost of labor between the two locations. Beyond that offshoring will be more “merit-based” and not as reckless as it currently is for many companies.
One scenario is that co-sourcing will gain prominence with “best-sourcing”, selective outsourcing for activities which deliver maximum value from offshore. The boys and men will also standout once the wave of the reckless outsourcing receedes and a major phase of consolidation will ensue among India based IT service providers.